The man who has been accused of sparking the AIDS
epidemic for decades might not have had anything to do with the onset of the
disease, a new study has found.
Gaetan Dugas, a Quebec-born flight attendant at Air
Canada, was labeled as Patient Zero in a 1984 study by the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention (CDC).
Journalist Randy Shilts described Dugas as a promiscuous
man who recklessly continued to have sex with other men despite knowing he was
at risk of transmitting the virus in his 1987 book And The Band Played On.
But now, researchers at the University of Arizona in
Tucson have studied the history of the virus's mutations and found that the
epidemic began before Dugas's time - and at a different place, Science
reported.
Scientists compared a 1983 blood sample from Dugas with
eight blood samples taken from gay and bisexual men in the late 1970s.
They isolated the HIV and, thanks to a technique known
as the molecular clock, created a 'family tree' of the virus's different
versions throughout the years.
Dugas's version of the virus fell in the middle of the
tree, Science wrote, not at the beginning - showing that Dugas did not bring
the first case to the United States.
Instead, scientists say that the epidemic most likely
began around 1970 in New York City and that the virus had probably come from
Haiti or another Caribbean country.
Dugas was used as a scapegoat at the beginning of the
epidemic, Dr Richard Elion told Vox.
Gregg Gonsalves, an HIV/AIDS activist, told the website:
'Patient Zero became a convenient symbol for a culture ready to panic about gay
men and the microbes swirling around in their bodies.'
People Magazine singled out Dugas in 1987 as one of the
25 most intriguing people of the year, saying that his 'fierce sexual drive
gave impetus to an epidemic that claimed his life and thousands more'.
That same year, Time Magazine spread a similar narrative
about Dugas, calling Shilts's account of the epidemic 'a stunning book'.
The New York Post called Dugas 'The Man Who Gave Us
Aids' in a headline, Science of Us reported.
Shilts's book, in which two doctors call Dugas a
sociopath, attracted criticism later on for being speculative and relying too
much on rumors, Dr Richard A McKay wrote in a 2014 study.
Dugas was born in Quebec City in 1952. He moved to
Vancouver when he was 20 years old to learn English and get his dream job as a
flight attendant.
He began working for Air Canada in 1974 and traveled
often between Vancouver, Montreal, Halifax and Toronto. Dugas, who had 'several
hundred partners each year' according to McKay, also spent time in New York in
San Francisco.
He was diagnosed with Kaposi's Sarcoma, a type of cancer
frequently found in AIDS patients, in 1980.
'With an awareness of the limits of contemporary
knowledge about the condition, Dugas was one of many gay men of the time who
viewed medical claims and advice with skepticism,' McKay wrote.
'Nonetheless, he had been very helpful with researchers
from the CDC, providing them in 1982 with the best early set of records for
contact tracing they could find—seventy-two names of his previous sexual
contacts.'
Dugas died in Quebec City in 1984, at 31 years old.
0 comments:
Post a Comment